Our Flavors

We rotate through 150 unique homemade flavors, including our creamy Upstate dairy flavors, lactose-free, vegan, sorbet and no sugar added. We're only able to scoop 28 of these flavors at one time. Stop by to see what the flavor line up is today!

Adam's Above Average CheesecakeBrownie ice cream loaded with real cheesecake pieces and swirls of peanut butter. Adam's special creation! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Eggs, Gluten, Soy
All The Good StuffVanilla ice cream with a few of our favorite things: Oreos, brownies, cookie dough, fudge, and caramel swirls! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Almond JoyCoconut ice cream with sliced almonds and fudge swirls! Contains: Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts
Apple PieApple pie ice cream with real apples and pie pieces! Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Palm Oil
Apple Pie CrumbleContains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten
Apple-UmpkinA delicious blend of apple and pumpkin! Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten
Amaretti Amaretto flavored ice cream! Contains: Milk, Tree Nuts
Bailey's Irish CreamOur St. Patrick's Day creation! Made with real Bailey's Irish Cream. Must be over 21. Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk
Bananas FosterBanana flavored ice cream with a sweet swirl of banana, sugar, and rum! Contains: Milk
Bee's KneesA delicious combination of lavender and honey! Contains: Milk
Betty's Off Her RockerBetty's gone crazy with a delicious blend of cookie dough and brownie batter! Yum! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Big D's Serpent SupremeContains: Milk, Nuts, Soy
Black CherryBlack cherry ice cream with real black cherries! Contains: Milk, Red 40
Black Raspberry Classic black raspberry ice cream. Contains: Milk, Red 40
Blueberry CheesecakeVanilla ice cream with real cheesecake pieces and swirls of blueberry! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
Blueberry MuffinContains: Milk, Gluten
Blueberry PancakeBlueberry pancake flavored ice cream with real blueberries! Contains: Milk, Red 40
Blue MoonA fruity tuity ice cream and oh yeah, it's blue! Contains: Milk
Boss Lady's Take 4Cause she doesn't have the time to take 5! This salted caramel ice cream is loaded with chocolate covered pretzels and peanut butter swirls. Contains: Milk, Nuts, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Blue Raspberry SorbetNo dairy here! Just blue raspberry flavored ice. Vegan/GF
Bubble YumBlue raspberry flavored ice cream with real pieces of gum! Contains: Milk
Butter CrunchButter almond ice cream with toffee crunchettes! Contains: Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts, Palm Oil
Butter PecanButter pecan flavored ice cream with roasted pecans! Contains: Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts
Cantaloupe Fruity and fresh, made with local farm stand cantaloupes! Contains: Milk
Cappuccino CrunchCoffee ice cream with dark chocolate swirls and toffee piece crunch! Contains: Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts, Palm Oil
Caramel CheesecakeCheesecake ice cream with swirls of caramel and cheesecake pieces! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Caramel Pumpkin CheesecakeCheesecake ice cream with ripples of pumpkin caramel and cheesecake pieces! Contains: Milk, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Chef's KissAlmond cake ice cream with mascarpone frosting swirls, cake pieces and maraschino cherries! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Tree Nuts
Chewy Cold Brewy Teamin' up with Majestic Hill Coffee Roasters for this cold brew ice cream loaded with brownie pieces! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
ChocoholicThis ice cream is for the real chocolate fanatics! Chocolate ice cream with Oreos, brownies, and fudge! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
ChocolateClassic chocolate ice cream. Contains: Milk
Chocolate MarshmallowOur creamy chocolate ice cream with swirls of marshmallow! Contains: Milk, Eggs,
Christmas CookieSugar cookie ice cream with Christmas frosting and sprinkle swirls! Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
Cinnamon CrushHot cinnamon ice cream, not for the faint of heart! Contains: Milk, Red 40
Cinnamon RollCinnamon roll ice cream with swirls of cinnamon! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy
Coconut Cream PieCoconut cream custard ice cream with real pie pieces. Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Tree Nuts, Palm Oil
Coconut DreamDreaming about coconut ice cream? This is the flavor for you! Contains: Milk, Tree Nuts
Cookie ButterThe new spreadable craze has made its way to Warsaw! You've got to try this one! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Eggs, Gluten, Soy
Coffee & CookiesGet a jolt of caffeine and have your Oreos too! Contains: Milk, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Coffee MonsterCoffee ice cream with all of Cookie Monster's favorites - oreos, cookie dough bites and chocolate chips! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Cookie ButterA Biscoff cookie-infused ice cream you must try! Contains: Milk, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Cookie Dough CheesecakeCookie dough flavored ice cream with chocolate chips, cookie dough, and real cheesecake pieces! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Cookie MonsterOreos, cookie dough pieces, ad chocolate chips in cookie dough ice cream! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Cotton CandyPink & blue to make your dreams come true! Contains: Milk
Crush's Caramel CurrentVanilla ice cream swimming with caramel turtles in caramel current's. Rock on! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Soy
Cub PawsVanilla ice cream with peanut butter swirls and loads of peanut butter cups! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Soy
Cupcake CheesecakeSatisfy your sweet tooth with celebration of cheesecake ice cream and pieces of cupcake! Don't worry. we didn't forget the frosting! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Eggs, Gluten, Soy
Dark Chocolate Raspberry TruffleDark chocolate ice cream with raspberry swirls and truffles! Contains: Milk, Soy
Dark Side of HeavenDark chocolate ice cream with a heavenly blend of cookie dough and cheesecake pieces! Contains: Milk, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
Dreamsicle CreamsicleVanilla and orange combined for perfection! Contains: Milk
Egg NogA Christmas classic! Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Eggs
Frosted MaltA hint of chocolate with a lot of malt makes this creamy ice cream a blast from the past! Contains: Milk, Gluten
Fried DoughYour favorite fair food inspired this flavor! A simple cinnamon fried dough ice cream. Contains: Milk, Gluten
Genesee MudpieChocolate ice cream with pecans, Oreos, chocolate chips, and a river of marshmallow swirl! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Eggs, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Ginger SnapYour favorite cookie! Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy
Girl Scout CookieCoconut ice cream with caramel swirls and chocolate chips! Contains: Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts
Gotta Have S'moreGraham cracker ice cream with marshmallow swirls and loaded with chocolate chips! Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Graham-Sticky-TasticGraham cracker ice cream with swirls of graham cracker and sticky caramel! Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Heath CheesecakeCheesecake flavored ice cream with heath pieces and fudge swirls! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Palm Oil
Hello DollyYummies magical spin on Hello Dolly Bars (Magic Bars). Our graham cracker ice cream with crushed pecans and streaks of chocolate. Contains: Milk, Gluten, Soy, Tree Nuts
Holy CannoliCannoli flavored ice cream with lots of chocolate chips. Try it in our fresh baked waffle cone for the divine experience! Contains: Milk
Kaleigh's Kahlua KickKahlua ice cream with coffee and toffee pieces! Must be 21. Contains: Milk, Tree Nuts
Key Lime PieKey lime flavored ice cream with swirls of graham cracker! Contains: Milk, Gluten, Palm Oil
Lemon MerinqueLemon flavored ice cream with graham cracker and whipped! Contains: Milk, Gluten
Lemon Raspberry CheesecakeLemon flavored ice cream with raspberry swirls and real cheesecake pieces! Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
Lemon SorbetDairy-free, light and refreshing! Vegan/GF
LoganberryA real Western New York classic! What is Loganberry? Contains: Milk
Logan's Chocolate PBLogan's favorite! Chocolate ice cream with swirls of peanut butter! Contains: Milk, Nuts
Malted HeathMalted ice cream loaded with Heath pieces! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Soy, Palm Oil
Mango SorbetNo dairy here! Just mango flavored ice! Vegan/GF
Maple BaconWe're tappin' the trees and makin' the bacon with this seasonal favorite! Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk
Maple I'm AmazedThere's no maybe's about being amazed by this maple ice cream with browned buttered swirls and cinnamon streusel pieces. Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Maple WalnutMaple ice cream with walnuts of course! Contains: Milk, Tree Nuts
Max Black PB AttackPeanut butter ice cream with chocolate crinkle cookies and fudge swirls! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Egg, Gluten, Soy
Mo's Mocha MadnessMocha ice cream with Oreos and swirls of caramel! Contains: Milk, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Mom's No-Bake CookiePeanut butter chocolate ice cream with oats. Just like your mom's! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Gluten
Mom's Coffee ToffeeAny parent will get the boost of energy they need with this coffee ice cream loaded with Heath pieces! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Soy, Palm Oil
Monkey MayhemDo you love bananas, Nilla wafers, whipped cream and chocolate? Then you'll love this flavor! Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Muddy Frog Mint ice cream with Oreos, brownies, and fudge swirls! Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Oh My OatmealOatmeal ice cream with oats and butterscotch chips! Contains: Milk, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Olaf's Frozen Hot CocoaThe hot and the cold are both so intense. Put 'em together - it just makes sense! Contains: Milk, Egg
Ooey Gooey BrownieBrownie ice cream with swirls of chocolate and brownie pieces! Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Orange Cream SorbetCold and refreshing dairy free orange cream delight! Vegan/GF
Orange PineappleOrange you glad it's pineapple! Contains: Milk
Oreo CrumbleOur 2021 People's Choice winner! Warsaw student Sophia created this chocolate ice cream that's loaded with Oreos and chocolate chips! Contains: Milk, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Party TimeBirthday cake ice cream with a party of sprinkles and frosting! Contains: Milk, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
PB Chip YogurtVanilla frozen yogurt with pb swirls and fudge flakes! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Soy
PB Galore & MorePeanut butter ice cream with PB cups and fudge swirls! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Egg, Gluten, Soy
PB OreoChocolate peanut butter ice cream with Oreos! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
PB S'moreGraham cracker ice cream with marshmallow, peanut butter swirls, and loaded with chocolate chips! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Peanut Butter Jelly TimeCombining two classics- vanilla ice cream and PB&J! Contains: Milk, Nuts,
PeachIt's just peachy ice cream! Contains: Milk
Peach SorbetNo dairy here. Just delicious peach sorbet! Vegan/GF
Peep-A-BooMarshmallow ice cream with peek-a-boo Peeps! Contains: Milk, Egg, Soy
PeppermintPeppermint flavored ice cream with peppermint pieces. Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Soy
Pina ColadaThe perfect combination of coconut and pineapple! Contains: Milk, Tree Nuts
Pina Colada SorbetA delicious blend of coconut and pineapple! Contains: Milk
Paul's PistachioMy dad's favorite! With lots of pistachios of course! Contains: Milk, Tree Nuts
Pucker UpPucker up and enjoy this lemon flavored custard! Contains: Milk
PumpkinA fall classic! Contains: Milk
Pumpkin CheesecakePumpkin ice cream with cheesecake pieces. Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
Rainbow Sherbet Enjoy lime, orange and raspberry all at once! Contains: Milk
Raspberry CheesecakeCheesecake flavored ice cream with swirls of raspberry and real cheesecake pieces. Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
Raspberry SorbetDairy-free and berry delicious! Vegan/GF
Red VelvetRed velvet ice cream with ripples of cream cheese! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Egg, Gluten, Soy
Red, White and BlueberryVanilla ice cream with swirls of raspberry and blueberry. Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Soy, Red 40
Reese MarshmallowOur 2022 People's Choice winner! Created by Warsaw student Hanna, this flavor is peanut butter ice cream with Reese's Pieces and marshmallows! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Egg, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
Rockin' RaspberryWhite chocolate ice cream with raspberry swirls and lots of chocolate chips. Contains: Milk, Soy, Red 40
Rootin' Tootin' RootbeerRootbeer ice cream, swirled with our creamy vanilla - just like a float! Contains: Milk
Rum Cha ChaRumchata ice cream! Must be 21 Contains: Milk, Gluten
Rum RaisinWe are bringing back memories with this classic! Rum flavored ice cream with lots of raisins! Contains: Milk
Sarah's Boston DreamSarah's love for Boston Cream Donuts inspired this Bavarian cream ice cream with pastry pieces and chocolate flakes! Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy
Salty Sea and Pretzely Sea salt caramel ice cream with swirls of salty caramel and chocolate covered pretzels. Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil
SS Caramel A sea of salty caramel ice cream with seas salt caramel truffles. Contains: Milk, Soy, Palm Oil
Snap, Crackle, PopButtery marshmallow ice cream with pieces of rice krispie treats! Contains: Milk, Soy, Palm Oil
Snickers CheesecakeA combination of cheesecake flavored ice cream and Snickers candy bar pieces. Contains: Milk, Nuts, Egg, Soy, Palm Oil
Sponge CandyCaramel flavored ice cream with Oliver's Sponge Candy! How could you go wrong? Contains: Milk, Soy
SpotlightButtered popcorn flavored ice cream with sea salt caramel truffles and sea salt caramel swirls. Contains: Milk, Soy, Palm Oil
StrawberryA classic! Strawberry ice cream with strawberries! Contains: Milk, Red 40
Strawberry BananaGo bananas over our strawberry ice cream with bananas! Contains: Milk, Red 40
Strawberry CheesecakeOur superior Vanilla ice cream with strawberries and real cheesecake pieces. Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
Strawberry ShortcakeOur superior Vanilla ice cream with strawberries, whipped cream, and shortcake pieces hand stirred in. Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Red 40
Strawberry SorbetNo dairy here. Just strawberry flavored ice. Vegan/GF
Strawberry Lemonade SorbetA deliciously refreshing lemonade flavored ice! Vegan/GF
Sunshine and Blue SkiesLemon flavored ice cream with blueberry swirls. Contains: Milk, Red 40
Sunshine on a BeachStrawberry ice cream with a combination of graham cracker, cheesecake and marshmallow swirls! This flavor was created by Attica's 3rd grader, Taylor, and won our 2023 March Madness! Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
Sticky FingersButterfinger pieces and caramel swirled into sea salt caramel ice cream! Contains: Milk, Nuts, Soy, Palm Oil
Sugar Shanty SpecialVanilla ice cream with swirls of maple syrup and maple coated nuts. Seasonal Flavor. Contains: Milk, Nuts
Taylor's Dark Chocolate AlmondDark chocolate ice cream with slivered almonds - Taylor's favorite! Contains: Milk, Tree Nuts, Soy, Red 40
Terri's Guilty PleasureCreamy white chocolate ice cream with oatmeal cookie pieces! Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy
Tiger TraxCelebrating our hometown with vanilla ice cream, fudge swirls, and peanut butter cups. Contains: Milk, Nuts, Gluten, Soy
Thick MintYummies' darkest chocolate with Girl Scout Thin Mints. Contains: Milk, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil, Red 40
Turtle CheesecakeChocolate ice cream with caramel swirls, pecans and cheesecake bites. Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy, Tree Nuts, Palm Oil
Twixted SisterVanilla ice cream rockin' with Twix and caramel. Contains: Milk, Nuts, Egg, Soy
VanillaCreamy vanilla ice cream! Contains: Milk
Wake Up WarsawWayne says, "Wake up Warsaw" with this coffee bean ice cream! Contains: Milk
Watermelon SorbetThis dairy free option screams summertime! Vegan/GF
Whiskey BusinessWhiskey flavored ice cream with pecan pieces and swirls of sea salt caramel. Contains: Milk, Tree Nuts
White LightningDark Chocolate ice cream with marshmallow swirls. Contains: Milk, Soy, Red 40
Yummies Takes The CakeYellow cake batter ice cream with fudge swirls and cake pieces. Contains: Milk, Egg, Gluten, Soy

Our Flavors

Connect with us

Location

Hours