Our Flavors

We make over 100 unique flavors. We're scoopin' only 28 of those flavors at one time, including our creamy Upstate mix flavors, Upstate lactose free, NSA, sorbet and vegan. Unfortunately we cannot scoop them all at once, we wish we could!

Adam's Above Average CheesecakeBrownie ice cream loaded with real cheesecake pieces and swirls of peanut butter. Adam's special creation!
All The Good StuffVanilla ice cream with a few of our favorite things: Oreos, brownies, cookie dough, fudge, and caramel swirls!
Banana FosterBanana flavored ice cream with a sweet swirl of banana, sugar, and rum!
Betty's Off Her RockerBetty's gone crazy with a delicious blend of cookie dough and brownie batter! Yum!
Black Raspberry Classic black raspberry ice cream.
Blue MoonA fruity tuity ice cream and oh yeah, it's blue!
Black CherryBlack cherry ice cream with real black cherries!
Blueberry CheesecakeVanilla ice cream with real cheesecake pieces and swirls of blueberry!
Blue Raspberry SorbetNo dairy here! Just blue raspberry flavored ice.
Blueberry PancakeBlueberry pancake flavored ice cream with real blueberries!
Bubble YumBlue raspberry flavored ice cream with real pieces of gum!
Butter CrunchButter almond ice cream with toffee crunchettes!
Butter PecanButter pecan flavored ice cream with roasted pecans!
Caramel CheesecakeCheesecake ice cream with swirls of caramel and cheesecake pieces!
CherrynillaVanilla ice cream with maraschino cherries. Yum!
ChocolateClassic chocolate ice cream.
ChocoholicThis ice cream is for the real chocolate fanatics! Chocolate ice cream with Oreos, brownies, and fudge!
Chocolate AlmondChocolate ice cream with lots of almonds!
Chocolate PB CookieChocolate ice cream with PB cookies!
Cinnamon CrushHot cinnamon ice cream, not for the faint of heart!
Cinnamon RollCinnamon roll ice cream with swirls of cinnamon!
Coconut DreamDreaming about coconut ice cream? This is the flavor for you!
Cookie ButterThe new spreadable craze has made its way to Warsaw! You've got to try this one!
Coffee & CookiesGet a jolt of caffeine and have your Oreos too!
Cupcake CheesecakeSatisfy your sweet tooth with celebration of cheesecake ice cream and pieces of cupcake! Don't worry. we didn't forget the frosting!
Cookie DoughCookie dough flavored ice cream with cookie dough pieces and chocolate chips!
Cookie Dough CheesecakeCookie dough flavored ice cream with chocolate chips, cookie dough, and real cheesecake pieces!
Cookie MonsterOreos, cookie dough pieces, ad chocolate chips in cookie dough ice cream!
Cookies 'N CreamHow can you go wrong with creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with Oreos!
Cotton CandyPink & blue to make your dreams come true!
Crush's Caramel CurrentVanilla ice cream swimming with caramel turtles in caramel current's. Rock on!
Cub PawsVanilla ice cream with peanut butter swirls and loads of peanut butter cups!
Dark Chocolate Raspberry TruffleDark chocolate ice cream with raspberry swirls and truffles!
Dreamsicle CreamsicleVanilla and orange combined for perfection!
Frosted MaltA hint of chocolate with a lot of malt makes this creamy ice cream a blast from the past!
Emma's Gone BananasBanana ice cream with bananas foster swirls!
Girl Scout CookieCoconut ice cream with caramel swirls and chocolate chips!
Gotta Have S'moreGraham cracker ice cream with marshmallow swirls and loaded with chocolate chips!
Graham-Sticky-TasticGraham cracker ice cream with swirls of graham cracker and sticky caramel!
Heath CheesecakeCheesecake flavored ice cream with heath pieces and fudge swirls!
Holy CannoliCannoli flavored ice cream with lots of chocolate chips. Try it in our fresh baked waffle cone for the divine experience!
Honey Moo MooIce cream has never been so good for you! Fresh ground cinnamon and locally sourced honey have been combined to create this "healthy", creamy ice cream!
Junior MintCreamy, minty ice cream with junior mints swirled throughout!
Just Dew ItMountain Dew flavored ice cream!
Kaleigh's Kahlua KickKahlua ice cream with coffee and toffee pieces!
Key Lime PieKey lime flavored ice cream with swirls of graham cracker!
Lemon MerinqueLemon flavored ice cream with graham cracker and whipped!
Lemon Raspberry CheesecakeLemon flavored ice cream with raspberry swirls and real cheesecake pieces!
LoganberryA real Western New York classic! What is Loganberry?
Logan's Chocolate PBLogan's favorite! Chocolate ice cream with swirls of peanut butter!
Genesee Mud PieChocolate ice cream with pecans, Oreos, chocolate chips, and a river of marshmallow swirl!
Malted HeathMalted ice cream loaded with Heath pieces!
Mango SorbetNo dairy here! Just mango flavored ice!
Maple WalnutMaple ice cream with walnuts of course!
Max Black PB AttackPeanut butter ice cream with chocolate crinkle cookies and fudge swirls!
Mint ChipWho can resist mint ice cream with chocolate chips?
Mint OreoMint ice cream and Oreo cookies!
Mo's Mocha MadnessMocha ice cream with Oreos and swirls of caramel!
Mocha Coffee CrunchMocha ice cream with chocolate covered coffee beans and Oreos.
Mom's Coffee ToffeeAny parent will get the boost of energy they need with this coffee ice cream loaded with Heath pieces!
Maple BaconWe're tappin' the trees and makin' the bacon with this seasonal favorite!
Muddy Frog Mint ice cream with Oreos, brownies, and fudge swirls!
Ooey Gooey BrownieBrownie ice cream with swirls of chocolate and brownie pieces!
Orange Cream SorbetCold and refreshing dairy free orange cream delight!
Orange PineappleOrange you glad it's pineapple!
Party Like It's 1999Birthday cake ice cream with a party of sprinkles and frosting!
Olaf's Frozen Hot CocoaThe hot and the cold are both so intense, put 'em together it just makes sense!
PB Galore & MorePeanut butter ice cream with PB cups and fudge swirls!
PB OreoChocolate peanut butter ice cream with Oreos!
PB S'moreGraham cracker ice cream with marshmallow, peanut butter swirls, and loaded with chocolate chips!
PeachIt's just peachy ice cream!
Peach SorbetNo dairy here. Just delicious peach sorbet!
Peanut Butter Jelly TimeCombining two classics- vanilla ice cream and PB&J!
Peep-A-BooMarshmallow ice cream with peek-a-boo Peeps!
Pina ColadaThe perfect combination of coconut and pineapple!
Pina Colada SorbetA delicious, dairy free blend of coconut and pineapple!
Paul's PistachioMy dad's favorite! With lots of pistachios of course!
Pokeball PunchI choose you, tart cherry and vanilla! Catch 'em both in this ice cream.
Pucker UpPucker up and enjoy this lemon flavored custard!
PVPPeanut butter ice cream with vanilla chips and swirls of peanut butter and fudge!
PumpkinA fall classic!
Raspberry CheesecakeCheesecake flavored ice cream with swirls of raspberry and real cheesecake pieces.
Rockin' RaspberryWhite chocolate ice cream with raspberry swirls and lots of chocolate chips.
Rum RaisinWe are bringing back memories with this classic! Rum flavored ice cream with lots of raisins!
SS Caramel A sea of salty caramel ice cream with seas salt caramel truffles.
Salty Sea and Pretzely Sea salt caramel ice cream with swirls of salty caramel and chocolate covered pretzels.
Snickers CheesecakeA combination of cheesecake flavored ice cream and Snickers candy bar pieces.
Sophia's Poppin' Rockin'Cotton candy flavored ice cream with lots of pop rock candies.
Sponge CandyCaramel flavored ice cream with Oliver's Sponge Candy! How could you go wrong?
SpotlightButtered popcorn flavored ice cream with sea salt caramel truffles and sea salt caramel swirls.
StrawberryA classic! Strawberry ice cream with strawberries!
Strawberry BananaGo bananas over our strawberry ice cream with bananas!
Strawberry CheesecakeOur superior Vanilla ice cream with strawberries and real cheesecake pieces.
Strawberry ShortcakeOur superior Vanilla ice cream with strawberries, whipped cream, and shortcake pieces hand stirred in.
Strawberry SorbetNo dairy here. Just strawberry flavored ice.
Sunshine and Blue SkiesLemon flavored ice cream with blueberry swirls.
Sweet Caramel Caramel never tasted so good...so good, so good, so good!
Terry's Guilty PleasureDelicious white chocolate ice cream with oatmeal cookie pieces.
Tiger TraxCelebrating our hometown with vanilla ice cream, fudge swirls, and peanut butter cups.
Twixted SisterVanilla ice cream rockin' with Twix and caramel.
VanillaCreamy vanilla ice cream!
VeganWe are always scoopin' vegan options! Just ask what we're scoopin' today!
Wake Up WarsawWayne says, "Wake up Warsaw" with this coffee bean ice cream!
Watermelon SorbetThis dairy free option screams summertime!
Whiskey BusinessWhiskey flavored ice cream with pecan pieces and swirls of sea salt caramel.
Yippee SkippeeThis vanilla ice cream with chocolate covered coffee beans and sea salt caramel swirls is sure to put a little skip in your step!
Yummy Blackberry CheesecakeBlackberries swirled into cheesecake ice cream.

Our Flavors

Want your own flavor?

Connect with us

Location

Hours